Post by messi05 on Jan 24, 2024 7:22:40 GMT -4
In compliance with the principles of proportionality and reasonableness, teenagers up to 18 years of age have the right to travel by plane without having to present a photo ID, as this is permitted for children under 12 years of age. This was decided by the substitute federal judge of the 13th Federal Court Rodrigo de Souza, who authorized a 13-year-old girl to board with only her birth certificate. Souza understood that the 2016 resolution of the National Civil Aviation Agency that restricted the possibility to children under 12 years of age has no effect.
By making this differentiation, states Buy Phone Number List the judge, Anac offends basic principles of the Federal Constitution. He also highlights that the agency allows, on domestic flights, boarding without a photo ID in exceptional situations, such as in cases of robbery and theft, as long as a Police Report issued by the competent public security authority is presented. The action was filed against Anac and Gol Linhas Aéreas. The judge, however, states that the company did not commit any illegality, despite having caused harm to the young woman. Lawyer Jacó Coelho acted in the case and states that, despite having acted in the exercise of regulatory activity, Anac, by making the use of birth certificates for teenagers unfeasible, creates a situation that violates the principles of proportionality and reasonableness.
In this specific case, he explains that the young woman even had a judicial authorization. “The minor intended to travel within the national territory with her own mother, has a certificate, CPF and travel authorization issued by the Child and Youth Law Court. It is reasonable to assume that she does not yet have an identity card or passport. Therefore, I don’t see any justification for requiring photo identification”, he argues. The judge granted the anticipation of the effects of guardianship to grant travel authorization. In case of non-compliance, the airline is subject to a daily fine of R$1,000.The note states that the legal principle of equality is a mirror of society and that it has undergone “transmutations” over time: “In this sense, the equality of days gone by may not correspond to what is envisioned as equality today”, it concludes.
By making this differentiation, states Buy Phone Number List the judge, Anac offends basic principles of the Federal Constitution. He also highlights that the agency allows, on domestic flights, boarding without a photo ID in exceptional situations, such as in cases of robbery and theft, as long as a Police Report issued by the competent public security authority is presented. The action was filed against Anac and Gol Linhas Aéreas. The judge, however, states that the company did not commit any illegality, despite having caused harm to the young woman. Lawyer Jacó Coelho acted in the case and states that, despite having acted in the exercise of regulatory activity, Anac, by making the use of birth certificates for teenagers unfeasible, creates a situation that violates the principles of proportionality and reasonableness.
In this specific case, he explains that the young woman even had a judicial authorization. “The minor intended to travel within the national territory with her own mother, has a certificate, CPF and travel authorization issued by the Child and Youth Law Court. It is reasonable to assume that she does not yet have an identity card or passport. Therefore, I don’t see any justification for requiring photo identification”, he argues. The judge granted the anticipation of the effects of guardianship to grant travel authorization. In case of non-compliance, the airline is subject to a daily fine of R$1,000.The note states that the legal principle of equality is a mirror of society and that it has undergone “transmutations” over time: “In this sense, the equality of days gone by may not correspond to what is envisioned as equality today”, it concludes.